| =5 | Bald Ranch Creston District · Cabernet Sauvignon · Creston Seven wines, four decades, and no Cabernet vintage below 88 since 2017 — the $45 fee is the only thing here that is not refunded. | | 94 | $90 | 84 | +11 |
| =37 | York Mesa Creston District · Petite Sirah · Creston Four wines, walk-in, $45 to sit down and 79 for transparency — York Mesa would rather pour than explain. | | 89 | $64 | 84 | +6 |
| =57 | Boye Cellars Creston District · Mourvèdre · Creston Fourteen thousand estate cases, no appointment needed, and vintages that swing from 79 to 91 — buy by the year, not the label. | | 87 | $78 | 83 | +4 |
| =57 | Calder Draw Creston District · Merlot · Creston Declines to disclose its additions and owns no vineyard, which is 70 for transparency and an honest zero for estate fruit. | | 87 | $64 | 88 | +4 |
| =57 | Vineyard Grade Creston District · Albariño · Creston Thirty-five dollars for Creston Albariño with a value score of 99 — the cheapest Albariño Cruxvine scores, by half. | | 87 | $35 | 99 | +4 |
| =76 | Cañada Springs Creston District · Mourvèdre · Creston A $45 fee and a value score of 71 on Creston Mourvèdre grown 65% on the estate; the room is better than the maths. | | 86 | $86 | 71 | +3 |
| =88 | Amsel Gate Creston District · Grenache · Creston Named tastings, 92% estate, and a room at 77 — Amsel Gate is better in the glass than across the counter. | | 85 | $72 | 80 | +2 |
| =104 | Huer Huero Gate Creston District · Tempranillo · Creston Nineteen wines out of twenty-two hundred cases is a range problem, not a quality one; the Tempranillo holds it together. | | 84 | $73 | 76 | +1 |
| =118 | Corliss Hill Creston District · Picpoul Blanc · Creston Fourteen thousand cases from a house that owns nothing and says nothing; the room scores 72 and the Picpoul carries it. | | 83 | $69 | 85 | ±0 |
| =118 | Mabry & Thorne Creston District · Grenache · Creston Four wines, $44, walk-in, and thirty-eight years of Creston Grenache that has never tried to be more than pleasant. | | 83 | $44 | 88 | ±0 |
| =118 | Old Creek Wash Creston District · Merlot · Creston Publishes its full additions list at $46 with value at 89: quality of 80 is the honest ceiling, and nobody here pretends otherwise. | | 83 | $46 | 89 | ±0 |
| =118 | Orrick Hollow Creston District · Cabernet Sauvignon · Creston Nine thousand cases of $47 Cabernet with value at 92 — the best cheap red in Creston, from a house that owns no vines. | | 83 | $47 | 92 | ±0 |
| =118 | Tarrant & Bellamy Creston District · Tempranillo · Creston Sixteen wines, walk-in, $20 to taste, and a transparency score of 69 that the friendliness does not offset. | | 83 | $64 | 82 | ±0 |
| =137 | Mabry Mesa Creston District · Grenache · Creston Ninety-five dollars for Creston Grenache with value at 68, no vineyard and no additions list — priced on confidence alone. | | 82 | $95 | 68 | −1 |
| =147 | Marchetti Furrow Creston District · Petit Verdot · Creston Nineteen wines from eight hundred cases since 1972, at $43 with value at 91 — a half-century of doing too much, cheaply. | | 81 | $43 | 91 | −2 |
| =147 | Tarrant Knoll Creston District · Grenache · Creston Eighteen wines from eight hundred cases, free to taste, walk in — Tarrant Knoll would rather you tried everything than bought much. | | 81 | $65 | 78 | −2 |
| =179 | Fenwick & Fairbourne Creston District · Counoise · Creston Thirteen wines, a 68-point room, nothing disclosed, $40 — Fenwick & Fairbourne is the bottom of Creston and knows it. | | 76 | $40 | 82 | −7 |