| 4 | Kestrel & Quint Adelaida District · Petit Verdot · Paso Robles Consistency of 100 across ten vintages: eight wines, no misses, and a $105 ask that assumes you already knew. | | 95 | $105 | 79 | +8 |
| =9 | Amsel Hollow Adelaida District · Cabernet Sauvignon · Paso Robles The only transparency score of 100 in Paso Robles, on seventeen wines from fourteen hundred cases of Adelaida Cabernet. | | 93 | $86 | 87 | +6 |
| =9 | Oyster Crossing Adelaida District · Merlot · Paso Robles Nine thousand cases and a quality score of 97: the wine has outgrown both the room and the pricing. | | 93 | $94 | 80 | +6 |
| =13 | Boye & Yarrow Adelaida District · Zinfandel · Paso Robles A hundred-point tasting room attached to fourteen hundred cases of estate Zinfandel; the hard part is getting the bottle, not the seat. | | 92 | $102 | 80 | +5 |
| =13 | Summit Estate Adelaida District · Tempranillo · Paso Robles Adelaida Tempranillo from 96% estate fruit, seven wines deep, priced at $90 and worth the argument. | | 92 | $90 | 87 | +5 |
| =19 | Wexler Crossing Adelaida District · Tempranillo · Paso Robles Nineteen wines, a 97-point room, and a value score of 73: Wexler Crossing sells the visit as much as the bottle. | | 91 | $108 | 73 | +4 |
| =19 | Wexler Draw Adelaida District · Mourvèdre · Paso Robles All estate fruit, $75, and a perfect value score — the 81 for the tasting room is the price of that. | | 91 | $75 | 100 | +4 |
| =30 | Hemsley & Ulmer Adelaida District · Zinfandel · Paso Robles Eight hundred cases, 40% estate, $104: you are paying for scarcity and for somebody else's vineyard. | | 90 | $104 | 81 | +3 |
| =30 | Jarrow Ranch Adelaida District · Viognier · Paso Robles Adelaida Viognier at $109 with a value score of 77 — a serious white asking a red's price. | | 90 | $109 | 77 | +3 |
| =37 | Limestone Winery Adelaida District · Counoise · Paso Robles Counoise, free to taste, no appointment, 96% estate — the most generous door in Adelaida attached to a grape nobody markets. | | 89 | $76 | 91 | +2 |
| =37 | Shell Vineyards Adelaida District · Roussanne · Paso Robles Nineteen Adelaida wines with a Roussanne at their centre, full additions published, and a value score of 78 that says so. | | 89 | $104 | 78 | +2 |
| =57 | Jessup Ranch Adelaida District · Mourvèdre · Paso Robles Publishes its full additions list on a hundred per cent estate fruit at $61 — the numbers here all point the same way. | | 87 | $61 | 80 | ±0 |
| =57 | Limestone Bend Adelaida District · Albariño · Paso Robles Albariño out of Adelaida limestone, eight hundred cases, fourteen wines — ambitious, and stretched thin because of it. | | 87 | $87 | 79 | ±0 |
| =76 | Fairbourne Bend Adelaida District · Merlot · Paso Robles Adelaida's oldest house, founded 1972, asking $101 for Merlot that scores 89 — value at 70 says the seniority is priced in. | | 86 | $101 | 70 | −1 |
| =76 | Salinas Rise Adelaida District · Tempranillo · Paso Robles Fifty-two years old, $61, $15 to taste and additions published — Salinas Rise has never made the visit expensive. | | 86 | $61 | 89 | −1 |
| =88 | Hemsley Grade Adelaida District · Counoise · Paso Robles Seventeen wines, no vineyard, no additions list — Hemsley Grade is a brand before it is a farm. | | 85 | $65 | 84 | −2 |
| =88 | Jarrow Grove Adelaida District · Cabernet Sauvignon · Paso Robles Eighteen wines from eight hundred cases at $47, walk-in, full additions published; consistency at 77 is the cost of that range. | | 85 | $47 | 91 | −2 |
| =88 | Lindqvist & Merriam Adelaida District · Grenache · Paso Robles Ninety-one for the wine, nothing disclosed, no estate fruit and $50 to taste: Adelaida Grenache on trust alone. | | 85 | $89 | 76 | −2 |
| =88 | Oakhurst Bend Adelaida District · Counoise · Paso Robles Four wines, free to taste, and a Counoise that has not moved much since 2004 — for better and for worse. | | 85 | $66 | 80 | −2 |
| =104 | Marrow Cellars Adelaida District · Zinfandel · Paso Robles Fifty-one years old, eight hundred cases, thirteen wines and a room at 89; the Zinfandel is the least interesting thing here. | | 84 | $83 | 72 | −3 |
| =104 | Steelhead Bench Adelaida District · Cabernet Sauvignon · Paso Robles A paying customer with a transparency score of 69, no estate fruit and no additions list — the score is 84 and the billing changed none of it. | | 84 | $57 | 88 | −3 |
| =118 | Cripple Cellars Adelaida District · Petite Sirah · Paso Robles A hundred and four dollars, value at 64, transparency at 68 and no estate fruit: the worst ratio in Adelaida. | | 83 | $104 | 64 | −4 |
| =118 | Naveau & Corliss Adelaida District · Counoise · Paso Robles A $50 fee for Counoise from a house with no vineyard and no additions list; value at 91 is the only defence offered. | | 83 | $55 | 91 | −4 |
| =179 | Kell Grove Adelaida District · Viognier · Paso Robles Fourteen thousand cases of Viognier from a 65-point room; 2024 is the best vintage, which is not saying a great deal. | | 76 | $50 | 77 | −11 |